Quantcast

Tracking On-Site Campaigns with Google Analytics, Part III: 4 pros and cons of Internal URL Referral Parameters


Facebook used to have them, Amazon still has them – parameters in the URL that show through which on-site campaign link the visitor has reached the current page. But unless you really have a thoroughly thought-through system in place, you should think twice about using them.

Internal Referral Parameters are not Campaign Parameters

First of all, let me clarify what I mean by “Internal Referral Parameters” (IRPs): Those are not to be confused with (external) Campaign Parameters (for Google Analytics, read “utm_campaign” and the like). As stated in the first article of this series, you should never use Campaign Parameters in the links of your on-site campaign because they will override the external source of the visitor. 

To give you an example for an IRP: If you visit Amazon.com’s homepage and click on “Books” in the left-hand navigation, you get to a page with the URL:

http://www.amazon.com/books-used-books-textbooks/b/ref=sa_menu_bo8?ie=UTF8&node=283155

See the “ref=sa_menu_bo8”? That is the IRP. It helps Amazon.com determine which links (=on-site campaigns) on its homepage, category pages, and so on are the most effective.

Another website that uses IRPs is YouTube. There, you often encounter URLs like

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxxxxxxx&feature=related

Here, the “feature” parameter is telling YouTube which link you used to get to the current video (in that case, I clicked on a “related video” on the right-hand side.


We stopped using them, and so did Facebook
My company used internal referral parameters for some months, but we stopped using them for the reasons I will explain in the full article. So has Facebook, which had used them extensively until a couple of months ago. They now seem to have dropped almost all URL parameters. Apart from the challenges those can cause for web analysts, they had other negative side effects: It was not easy, for example, to get a clean or “canonical” URL of your profile or fanpage because there always was “parameter clutter” attached to it, and every page existed in the form of countless URLs. You’d even see websites linking to the “wrong” (non-canonical) version of their fanpage. 

In the full article, I will look at four pros and cons of Internal Referral Parameters. Although they are easily combinable with conversion metrics and make some basic reporting easier, there are hefty issues like SEO problems, cluttered advanced reports and more work up-front if you want to avoid these problems. 

SEM Rush Review

The guys over at SEM Rush reached out to us recently and asked if we would consider reviewing the professional version of their toolkit. We are pretty selective about the product reviews we do on Web Analytics World but I was keen to do this review for a few reasons. For one these are the guys behind the legendary seoquake toolbar for firefox (one of the best free seo tools around) but in addition to this I am also a semi regular user of the very useful free online SEM Rush tools so I was keen to see what the pro version had to offer.

As active online marketers we have a bunch of tools and services which we use to varying degrees,  some free and some we pay for.  Often the biggest problem we find with the tools available is the range of things they claim to do  and the amount of cross over functionality between toolkits, so we find ourselves constantly trying to evaluate what does the best job for specific purposes.

One of the things I really like about SEM Rush is that it has a very defined purpose and specialises in a key area of online marketing. In a nutshell SEM Rush is all about maximising Google traffic and as such its toolkit helps with Keyword Research, Google Adwords Research & Competitor Analysis in these areas. Of course every online marketing toolkit claims to help with keyword research (and I have had a go at using most of them) however what separates SEM Rush from the others for me is the way it relates all data to relative commercial value by putting Adword data side by side with Keyword reports, competitor Analysis etc

Organic Keyword Research
So a basic keyword research screenshot of  www.webanalyticsworld.net  site is shown below. The data here at a glance is pretty useful as I can immediately see the commercial values of some of the keywords our site ranks for. Expanding this report would then give me the chance to spot highly commercial keywords with good search volume that our site ranks for but perhaps is sitting on page 2 or 3 on a Google search. I could then make some decisions to focus on these keywords from a promotion/seo perspective


Obviously decisions  around keywords also need to be in line with business strategy however you can see how this can be a useful tactic. One thing that I didn’t understand was the total number of keywords showing on our site (1085) when I know from our Analytics that this number is much much higher. I queried this with the guys at SEM Rush and they say that they focus on keywords with commercial value which is reasonable enough & their entire database has 88 million keywords across 36 million domains.

The basic report as shown to the right also gives you some data on site-wide Google traffic , indicating the monthly traffic coming from Google Searches, the estimated cost of purchasing the same amount of traffic (indicator of commercial value of organic traffic)  and the traffic volume from ads and related spend on Adwords

Google Adwords Keyword Research
I found the tool particularly useful for Adwords Research. The screenshot below shows a snapshot of a section of the adwords report again using Amazon.com as an example. You can immediately see all of the keywords Amazon are buying from Google Adwords. The geographic split allows you to drill down and find out how and what, they are advertising in specific geographies and clicking on the Ad icon to the left will actually show you the ad copy of a specific ad in question. In term of easy competitor Adwords analysis it doesn’t get much better than this. Clicking on a specific keyword will then take you to another report which will give you even more data on the keyword in question such as traffic, trends, competition as a well as some suggestions on related keywords and key phrases & organic sites ranking for this particular keyword.

Competitor Analysis
I hear lots of talk of competitor Analysis but rarely see any reporting mechanism on competitors that lead to actionable recommendations and associated tasks. Fundamentally it’s important to ask yourself why you want to analyse competitors.

Sure it’s nice to benchmark your site and see how well you are performing against your main rivals online but useful  competitor research should be more about looking out for best practice & learning from it as well as pulling out data based on key metrics allowing you to understand why one site outperforms another and actually come up with an actionable plan to gain traction, rankings, traffic and improve on a competitors position.

The SEMRush tools will allow you to do the basic competitor analysis but filter based on Search engine traffic (Google traffic), Traffic Price (commercial value of the traffic), number of ads running, ad traffic and ads traffic price. While this can paint a very interesting picture of competitors Google reach across the board some of the more useful interrogations of the SEMrush data would include:-

  • Identification of highly commercial keywords – Analyse keyword reports for competitors and look for new keywords with high CPC value and good search traffic.
  • Build out Keyword Lists- You could use related search analysis to analyse existing and new keywords to find variations, long tail versions etc which can be used on your web copy
  • Identify smart and relevant places to sell advertising -The Potential Ad Buyers Report will identify sites that buy Google Adwords keywords for terms that your site is naturally ranking for. This is a good indicator that they may be interested in your traffic and as a result may be willing to buy advertising space from your directly or through an ad network.
  • Identify smart and relevant places to advertise -This report will Analyse  what keywords you are bidding on and identify sites which naturally rank for those terms. This highlight the opportunities to contact site owners directly and either advertise directly with them or possibly even become a content contributor if you choose to go down the natural seo, link building route
  • View and analyse Adwords keywords, commercial value of keywords and ad copy -To be frank this allows you to spy on Adwords campaigns of your competitors, see where they are targeting geographically and what terms they are bidding on as well as the actually ad copy they are using in their campaigns
  • Find hidden related (and low-cost) keywords? -Focussing on high commercial value keyword and using the related keyword report you can often find low cost alternative keywords (low adwords cost) which are still very relevant and may convert just as well (related and long tail keywords)
  • Help to value a web property -The Traffic volume and relative valuation charts will help you when trying to assess the commercial value of any web property. There are many other factors to be considered here obviously but from a Search point of view this data is a big piece of the pie.
  • Other Fun Stuff – The feature ‘ups and downs’ shows a huge list of the top 1000 websites highlighting losses and gains in relation to Search Traffic, Cost of traffic, Number of Ads, Ad traffic, Cost of Ads. While this seems like a report that might not be directly relevant to your own online efforts the collation of this data makes for fascinating reading. You can see how this type of report can give some amazing insights into how Google is changing, the sites it favours and so.

A Combined Approach To Search & Conversion Optimisation

Too often the components which make up internet marketing are treated as individual silos, even when there are direct links between them. When the digital marketing mix is in synergy, all the elements can sit in the pockets of each other and provide incremental increases in sales numbers and most importantly, the bottom line.

This goes for the day to day interaction between operational team members in each field – only by discussing the digital marketing strategy as a whole, from as basic a principle as knowing what each other are doing and when, can the benefits be reaped. Identifying the key areas which lend a hand can lead to finding secret sauce which results in the optimal ROI.Pulling in the same direction

What I want to discuss in this article is the tight relationship between organic search and conversion optimisation. To illustrate this, let’s do a little dissection of the goals of SEO and CRO:

SEO: gain well placed rankings by proving to Google (or other engines) that a site or page is highly relevant to the user’s search query.

CRO: increase the ratio of visitors converted into customers by providing an experience which fulfils their intent to buy/sign-up etc.

(Note: For the purpose of this article the above are simplified, individual goals which make up part of SEO or CRO strategies)

Despite the difference in who is the judge of success in these cases (robots vs. humans, in a non-Terminator way), the key aim of both is to provide a relevant user experience which a) makes it easy to find what they want to purchase and b) makes it an easy decision and process to purchase the item.

From a conversion optimisation perspective, I find that often there are a number of common areas within SEO strategies for which a sharing of knowledge is mutually beneficial:

Informing Keyword Strategy

It is essential when reviewing a site’s conversion metrics that entrance source is taken into account, and is factored into the strategy for improvement. Specifically, by deriving (as you may guess, my favourite SEM word) intent from the the search queries that are driving visitors to pages we can gain vital insight into what messages are (or as importantly, are not) working for these user groups. To give a simple example, if most visitors are coming through ‘value’ focussed keywords, then we should make sure the space is used wisely by tailoring calls-to-action and copy to fulfil this intent.

The result of this is that we build up picture of performance metrics for a number of keyword categories. Plugging this into the SEO strategy provides great deal of insight about the profitability of potential keyword targets, allowing informed decisions to be made about which directions to take and what the required course of action is to meet any given targets.

Converting From The SERPs

In a CRO strategy, we need to look at the whole user journey, from the first query to the completion of a purchase and beyond.  It’s important to remember that, if you have a good level of organic search visibility, then it’s likely that your first interaction will be with your meta description. This is the chance to give your elevator pitch – in less than 155 characters you need to appeal to the intent (told you!) of the user type that will be provided a relevant, useful experience by your site/service. By focussing on finding these potential customers, all the onsite CRO work will prove even more beneficial by having a tailored audience. Only by working hand in hand with the SEO team can the meta description be tailored in such a way, whilst still ensuring it is highly optimised from an organic search perspective.

Profitable Pages

When investigating conversion performance, another key area to look at is which pages are getting the most organic traffic, and how efficient they are as landing pages at converting visitors into customers. If you can find pages which have a) high conversion rate for the traffic coming through them and b) a realistic potential for increasing traffic by optimising for the keywords driving visits, then the SEO strategy should be tailored accordingly. Even if it is a highly competitive area, the foundations provided by positive metrics on both sides of the coin should ensure that even slow progress will provide worthwhile uplifts in revenue.

The Negative Impact Of  Working in Silos

Results of poor teamwork

Needless to say, there are a huge number of ways in which different channels can support each other, the above only serving as an illustrative example of the myriad of ways and means. When there is a common goal between parties, sharing information can always serve to improve the results for all, so it’s vitally important that silos aren’t created which could lead to conflict or cannibalisation of efforts – e.g. when bidding there is a PPC bidding on keywords with an organic presence, duplicating the sales message would be cannibalistic, but taking the opportunity to give exposure to an alternative set of USPs increases the opportunity to appeal to a broader range of potential customers.

Targeted Internet Marketing: Past, Present & Future

Guest Post by Daniel Elroy

There is no doubt that Internet marketing has reached a crossroads. While social media platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter, have allowed businesses and brands unprecedented access to consumers, rising concerns over privacy    means that advertisers need to strike a delicate balance between ever-more targeted approaches and maintaining their customers’ trust. As former Google CEO Eric Schmidt famously put it while discussing Google’s own targeting policies, “Google policy is to get right up to the creepy line and not cross it.”

The history of targeted Internet marketing could perhaps be best described as a game of cat-and-mouse, where technological advances, consumer smarts, and government regulations chase one another up to that “creepy line” that continually gets redrawn. As technology moves faster, and the stakes for both marketers and consumers grow ever higher, both could benefit from a survey of the Internet marketing landscape: past, present, and future.

The Past: A World of Spam and Pop-Ups
Throughout the history of marketing, brands have attempted to effectively (and economically) reach potential customers while preventing their message from falling on deaf ears. The advent of the Internet age promised marketers an opportunity to finally place their message directly in front of those people who cared the most about their products. More than TV ads, more than mass mailers, more than print advertising, the Internet promised to replace blanket marketing with targeted campaigns.

However, technology needed to catch up. The early days of Internet marketing was still very much a one-way street. Marketers depended on the digital equivalent of junk mail and flyers to clog users’ inboxes or pop-up ads placed on websites supposedly popular with the same demographic as their products.

The low cost  of such digital marketing was attractive, but the actual results were arguably not any better than what could be achieved in the offline world.

The Present: Social Media Fever
Today’s Internet presents unprecedented opportunities for making marketing a two-way street. Technology and demand have met up in a landscape that is still under-regulated. As a result, businesses are pushing the envelope in a mad dash to identify and capture as many marketing impressions — and as much users’ information — as possible.

We are living in a world where marketers collect “likes” and “followers” as trophies. Marketers set traps with advertorial content, incentives, and any other bait available. All of these efforts are designed to make users click so that their own “likes” can be revealed for future targeted marketing messages.

At present, marketers have a clear advantage over consumers, who lack a full understanding of (or concern about) how their online behavior is targeted by marketing companies.

Future Prediction: The Customer Is King
In actuality, this prediction is the same reality that has always existed. No amount of marketing will sell a product that is unwanted by consumers. And targeting that crosses the line into “creepy” will have customers running the other direction in droves. The future will no doubt see a rise in more savvy consumers, armed with a fundamentally stronger understanding of how Internet marketing works. They will also have better tools to protect themselves from prying marketers, while government regulations will undoubtedly catch up with shadier industry practices.

How should marketers meet this future? With transparency, a compelling message, and the understanding that the customer is always right. No amount of SEO tricks, stealth cookies, Facebook “Likes,” and clever Tweets can replace satisfying consumers who want to follow and be loyal to a brand that targets their needs, desires, and interests without alienating them with shady practices. The Internet Marketing Jobs of the future will require a whole new suite of skills which are far more aligned to people skills and solid marketing that technology and trickry.

Is Your Internet Marketing Flexible?

Guest post by Melanie Durango

With the dynamic nature of the internet & the constant variations & changes in search engine algorithms the reality is that Internet marketing has to be a flexible activity. Search patterns are constantly changing as Internet users modify their online behaviour and search engines (and social media sites) evolve to deliver enhanced customer experience.

As a result online marketers need to respond with a flexible dynamic approach which adapts according to latest best practice. Whether you take care of online marketing within your own business or use an external internet marketing company, it’s important to realize that what works well today might not work as well next week. You must be ready to adjust your campaigns to match user behaviours.

Organic Search still more Important than Paid Search
The Company User Centric recently performed another study on search results favoured by Internet users. The outcome indicated yet again that users still overwhelmingly prefer organic search results. Regardless of search engine, it appears that most users still skip the paid results, and see the organic listings as being more relevant to their search query.

So Search engine optimization (SEO) should still be considered a fundamental part of any internet marketing strategy. As search engines evolve their ability to deliver users with increasingly relevant search results is constantly improving. As a result a big part of SEO is about understanding how search engine like Google determine the relevancy of a website to a particular topic. This however is a moving target so again SEO should be considered a dynamic art

Users Rely on Search Engines Less for Finding Specific Websites
Another trend emerging that Forrester Research points out, is that Internet users are relying less on search engines to find specific websites. While you might find that users rely on search engines to look for brands, reviews, products, and general information, they are less likely to use a search engine to find a specific website.

This is partly due to the fact that users are becoming ‘better’ at using the internet and will go straight to a web address (if they remember it). Coming up with a memorable web address for marketing purposes is therefore becoming more important. Google themselves have said that the current exact match domain name preference is something they are going to be looking at. In the future they are far more likely to favour the creative approach to domain names rather than the ‘what you see is what you get’ approach which has worked well in the past (from a straight Google ranking perspective) .

Social media sites are also having an impact on search engine activity and offering another route for users to find content, company websites etc. The power of user recommendation and referrals is also fairly strong within these sites. It’s important to find out which social media sites are most frequented by your target audience, and develop a strategy to interact in these places, placing content, engaging in discussion etc

Using Metrics to Measure Results
The importance of metrics to any online marketing effort is obviously paramount. Campaigns should have set key Performance indicators whether they are related to SEO, paid online ads, social media marketing etc. What is even more important is that web marketers act on these metrics and be prepared to adapt and change strategies, if something is no longer working.

Google Real time search update

Google Real Time Results
Google has been providing real time search results for a while now. These can be accessed by selecting the real time navigation option in the left hand bar which appears after performing a Google search. These real time results are also occasionally blended into the main Google search results in the same way they bring in images, video, new results etc. Obviously the exact mechanism which triggers these result being blended is part of Goggles Algorithm but there is an obvious link with popular events & topics that have lots of social media ‘noise’ associated with them.

 

google realtime search results image
google realtime search results

 

What’s changed with real time search results ?
Up until now these real time results have virtually all came from twitter mainly because of the deal struck between the two companies on data sharing. More recently Google made a significant change and is now bringing in real time results from other sources such as Quora, Gowalla, Facebook & several others. This brings a new dimension to real time results and makes this feature of search a bit more interesting for the end user

Real Time Search Results and Online marketing
So why is this important form an online marketing perspective ? . Initially it’s hard to see how this could have a direct influence on search engine optimization, being just a real-time random snapshot in time of tweets, mentions & comments etc.  However when you combine this functionality with Google’s social search which delivers personalized Google results based on your networks (facebook, twitter, LinkedIn etc) the possibilities for targeted online marketing become pretty interesting. As an example, consider promoting your own events using multiple social media channels and using the power of social search to deliver real time results to your own networks through Google.

Social Links in Search Engine Optimization
It’s also becoming clear that social media links are becoming a factor in SEO with facebook links, tweets etc all having some influence on search engine rankings. To what extent this is hard to quantify and while the biggest weapon in SEO is still the high authority back link, the weighting of social links is something that all internet marketing professionals should be monitoring very closely. The multi channel, blended approach to marketing on the internet is become increasingly important

Linkdex: SEO Campaign Organization & Management

I recently caught up with John Straw, CEO of Linkdex. Linkdex creates a SEO workflow that organizes campaigns on Google and Bing, as well as local engines with a step-by step task manager. The application aims to draw a solid line between SEO tasks and ROI. During our chat John gave me some insight on Linkdex:

[Manoj]: Give us the elevator pitch on Linkdex

[John Straw]: Linkdex is a fully integrated SEO toolset designed for small businesses, SEO professionals, and agencies looking to develop their skills in-house, putting process, protocol, and workflow into SEO, making an SEO program easy to manage.

[Manoj]: What was your motivation in developing it?

[John Straw]: I created one of the first SEO agencies in Europe in 2000. Running the business for 40 clients, I saw the world of SEO impenetrable for all but the very few well qualified consultants. Running a business on the back of multiple Excel spreadsheets and a bit of crude backlink analysis wasn’t exactly scalable. I wanted to put SEO (analysis and guided implementation) into the hands of everyone with a website.

[Manoj]: Tell us about how Linkdex helps folks new to leverage and learn SEO?

[John Straw]: We surveyed a lot of businesses last year to find out what they wanted in SEO. The overwhelming compelling top answer came back as “tell us what to do” so that’s what we do – we pre-populate task lists with everything from keyword research, positional reporting, onsite SEO, analytics, competitive analysis, link building and CRM. In addition, the task lists provide directions as to how to complete a task.

Probably our greatest feat is to have built a superior competitive analysis tool in the sector. We take a look at a competitive site, spider the backlink structure and curate it into categories: blogs, forums, news sites, PR sites, article sites, wiki’s, etc, all presented in bar charts. Click a bar and we present you with a list of target sites graded by relevance and influence. One click on a site listing and it pops into the CRM system for contact and relationship building. Analyzing a competitor’s links by category helps a company easily determine what linking strategies are best to pursue for themselves.

[Manoj]: What are the advantages of Linkdex in regards to managing the numerous tasks that are involved in SEO?

[John Straw]: So you probably use Outlook to organize your life and make it more effective. Linkdex is Outlook for SEO. When a customer reviews a list of tasks suggested by Linkdex they can drop the tasks into folders for completion with notes and assign tasks to other team members.

[Manoj]: What kinds of things will you be looking at in your product enhancement roadmap?

[John Straw]: We do plan to launch a version that meets the needs of boutique SEO agencies. Many of the top small SEO agencies are testing Linkdex now and providing great feedback. Beyond that we can’t discuss a roadmap right now as we are in the middle of the patent process for many of the more innovative features. However, we have a large development team using agile techniques. Our intention is to add a new feature every 2 weeks. So far we’re on track.